Testing Rails Validators

It’s challenging to test Rails custom validators.

I recently had to write a validator to require that an entered date is before or after a specified date.

It didn’t seem like writing the validator would be too difficult – I’ve written custom validators before, and date comparisons aren’t all that tricky. But when it came time to write the tests, I ran into several issues. And since I always try to follow TDD / test-first, I was blocked before I even began.

The biggest issue was the ActiveModel::EachValidator#validates_each API. It’s definitely not a well-designed API. You write your validator as a subclass, overriding validates_each. The method takes a model object, the name of the attribute of the model being tested, and the value of that attribute. You can also get the options passed to the custom validator via the options method. To perform a validation, you have to update the model’s errors hash.

The big flaw in the API is that instead of returning a result, you have to update the model. This needlessly couples the model and the validator. And it violates the Single Responsibility Principle — it has to determine validity of the field, and it has to update the errors hash of the model. This is not conducive to testing. Testing this method requires testing that the side-effect has taken place in the collaborator (model), which means it’s not really a unit test any more.

So to make it easier to unit test the validator, I broke the coupling by breaking it into 2 pieces, one for each responsibility. I moved the responsibility for determining validity to a separate method, which I called errors_for. It returns a hash of the errors found. This simplified the validates_each method to simply take the result of errors_for and update the errors hash of the model:

def validate_each(record, attribute_name, attribute_value)
  record.errors[attribute_name].concat(errors_for(attribute_value, options))

This made it much easier to unit test the errors_for method. This method doesn’t even need to know about the model — only about the value of the attribute we’re trying to validate. We simply pass in the attribute’s value and the options.

So we could write the tests without even pulling in ActiveRecord or any models:

describe DateValidator do
  let(:validator) { DateValidator.new(attributes: :attribute_name) }
  let(:errors) { validator.errors_for(attribute_value, validation_options) }

  describe 'when attribute value is NOT a valid date' do
    let(:attribute_value) { 'not a valid date' }
    it { errors.must_include 'is not a valid date' }

  describe 'when attribute value IS a valid date' do
    let(:attribute_value) { Date.parse('2013-12-11') }
    it { errors.must_be :empty? }

And the errors_for method looked something like this:

def errors_for(attribute_value, options)
  unless attribute_value.is_a?(Date)
    return [options.fetch(:message, "is not a valid date")]

Integration testing can also be a bit of a challenge. I recommend following the example from this Stack Overflow answer. Basically, create a minimal model object that contains the field and the validation. Then test that the model behaves like you expect with different values and validations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *